Showing posts with label academic freedom. Show all posts
Showing posts with label academic freedom. Show all posts

Saturday, July 20, 2013

Udacity On Pause at San Jose State

Udacity.com came on with a rush with high profile plans to aid education.  But it seems San Jose plans to take a breather on its association:
After six months of high-profile experimentation, San Jose State University plans to “pause” its work with Udacity, a company that promises to deliver low-cost, high-quality online education to the masses.
It might be low cost, but online education and classroom education are not the same things.  With the classroom as the standard, online is more akin to time with a librarian.  A very good learning experience, if done right, but different.  I suspect most online education is not unlike being alone in a library.  In any event, education is the one area where there is almost no valid and reliable studies because the money flows most to scammers.  Education, like medicine, could be fixed, but with "social engineering" the goal, the means will remain hijacked by ideologues, and the easily scammed, like Bill Gates.

EdX and Udacity, along with Coursera, are part of a trio of closely watched MOOC start-ups. MOOCs are not-for-credit, free online courses. The three startups are also branching out into other teaching and business models.

I bet they are.  There is one that brought the West from the "dark ages" to the enlightenment.  It would do well now.  But it would take deregulation and de-subsidizing education to achieve.  Just have the students pay the instructors directly.

Feel free to forward to three friends.

Tuesday, February 12, 2013

Cato Gets It Wrong

Cato is a putative free market think tank, and one of its "scholars" (from the greek, leisurely) advises we have free trade in education worldwide:

One way to promote free trade in higher education is with international trade agreements. 

But not really.  Free trade agreements are never about free trade, they are always bogus.  The only free trade possible is unilaterally pursued.  Anything negotiated is always constrained, not free.

So Cato uses the right words, but means nothing of the sort.  Only Seattle Teachers' College pursues free trade in education worldwide.

Sunday, February 3, 2013

Student's Work Owned By School

Prince George County Schools wants to make it so...  who knows, some public school kid, sometime, somewhere, might actually produce something worthwhile, even profitable, at which point the school wants it.  It is possible somebody in a government school might produce something.

“Works created by employees and/or students specifically for use by the Prince George’s County Public Schools or a specific school or department within PGCPS, are properties of the Board of Education even if created on the employee’s or student’s time and with the use of their materials,” the policy reads. “Further, works created during school/work hours, with the use of school system materials, and within the scope of an employee’s position or student’s classroom work assignment(s) are the properties of the Board of Education.”

What happened to grateful students making donations?

The measure has some worried that by the system claiming ownership to the work of others, creativity could be stifled and there would be little incentive to come up with innovative ways to educate students. Some have questioned the legality of the proposal as it relates to students.

Once we have the idea of intellectual property rights, and the supremacy of the state, ther eis no logical limit to state power.  It is all ours.


Friday, January 25, 2013

Reviewing Lynda.com

I have submitted a course to Lynda.com with a view to reviewing how it works.  I continuously survey the opportunities for teachers to teach, what I call student-employed college instructors, or the German call privatdozents, or is it privatdozenten?  I filled out the form on this their "call for teachers" page.

Here a week later and no reply.  Every time I look at one of these sites I check out their "press" or media link and my heart sinks when I see "round two financing" or whatever because it can be accurately translated "screw the instructors."  When education becomes a business, someone has to get screwed, and the easiest target is the instructors, because they are the only ones who care, so they will compromise on money.

Lynda.com is not unique in this, it is baked into capitalism.  Education is like medicine, it is not quite a market event.  It is certainly an economic event, but not adaptable to a profit model.  Education works best on the cooperative model, like medicine.

There are various versions of lynda.com out there, straighterline, etc... made possible because the present alternatives are so bad.  But things are changing.

But in USA we have the false dilemma of "business model" vs "socialisr model" in both education and medicine.  And that is why education and medicine is so backwards in USA, very expensive and poor results.

If you disagree regarding expensive and poor results, then you are unaware what both can be, if freed from state intervention.

In the meantime, I'd love to see an "education" website answer a potential instructor within 24 hours.  But then, why bother?  It's about the money.

Feel free to forward this to three friends.

Saturday, December 22, 2012

Advice on Continuing Education Programs

Here a California State educator lays out advice for continuing education programs.  Click through and download the .pdf.  It is a pretty good handbook on running a program.  It is remarkable for the granularity of the understanding of the field as it is in California today.

Tuesday, December 11, 2012

Wy They No Longer Teach Latin

Because people might start getting ideas...

"Quid autem interest quomodo sapiens ad otium veniat, utrum quia res publica illi deest an quia ipse rei publicae, si omnibus defutura res publica est?" (Seneca, de otio, 8.2)


in this case, otium is time characterized by private/social reading/writing as opposed to public involvement (sylvias explanation)

"But what does it matter how a wise man comes to otium, whether because the state is unavailable to the man or the man is unavailable to the state - if the state is going to fail everyone, no matter what? " ( trans sarah stroup from her book catullus, cicero, and a society of patrons,

Sunday, October 21, 2012

You Cannot Make This Stuff Up


Minnesota Bans Free Online University Courses from Outside Minnesota
Gary North
Printer-Friendly Format

Oct. 20, 2012
The state of Minnesota has discovered a fiendish plot against the residents of the state. Thirty-three major universities are offering free courses online.
The state has warned its residents not to take these courses.
Why not? Because the law says that no out-of-state university can sell education in Minnesota unless it is registered.
But the courses are free.
Yes, but they involve the use of time.
But the law -- decades old -- does not mention the spending of time. Only money.
Well, that doesn't matter. What matters is that the state of Minnesota is determined not to have its residents cheated of their valuable time by such fly-by night diploma mills as Princeton, Johns Hopkins, Cal Tech, Columbia, and Duke. No, sir. The residents of Minnesota are defenseless sitting ducks who must be protected from academic predators.
The target is Coursera, which makes these courses available online for free. No degrees are granted or promised.
Coursera has posted this warning on its site.
Coursera has been informed by the Minnesota Office of Higher Education that under Minnesota Statutes (136A.61 to 136A.71), a university cannot offer online courses to Minnesota residents unless the university has received authorization from the State of Minnesota to do so. If you are a resident of Minnesota, you agree that either (1) you will not take courses on Coursera, or (2) for each class that you take, the majority of work you do for the class will be done from outside the State of Minnesota.
The Department of Higher Education says that residents may take such courses if they are out of state at the time.
Across the Web, howls of derisive laughter have greeted the decree.
This policy by the state is an example of North's Law #1 of bureaucracy: "Some bureaucrat will eventually enforce the letter of the law to the point of absurdity."
In every bureaucracy, there will be a George Roedler. These people are determined. They say things that get normal people to start giggling uncontrollably, yet they say them with a straight face. Forbes reports:
Defending the statute, George Roedler, Manager of Institutional Registration & Licensing for the state of Minnesota says, "We regulate colleges & universities that enroll Minnesota residents. They are required to register as degree granting institutions with us." When I pointed out that students are not actually obtaining a degree upon the completion of these online courses, he argued that, "Our statute does not exempt free and non credit bearing courses."
At some point, the legislature will intervene and re-write the law. It will do this in order to get college-educated people around the world to stop giggling. It is one thing to have Garrison Keillor tease the state of Minnesota. But what if Jon Stewart does a segment on the The Daily Show?

Tuesday, September 11, 2012

Israel And University of California

The State of California passed a unanimous resolution directing its University system policies to forbid any teacher or student saying, among other things:

that Jews in America wield excessive power over American foreign policy;

Read the list of what is not allowed.  Surely something are already not allowed, but law, regardless of the topic.  So why only Jews?  This is a bad idea.

It is further reason why we need separation of school and state.